Dgwb blog white border

If it is true that transaction fees for payments are going to continue to fall, then what transaction fees will merchants pay instead?

My old friend Peter Vander Auwera posed a good question on Twitter recently. He asked:

Well I think I know the answer to this one. Not because I have any sort of crystal ball but because I can see the same trends that everyone else can see. The transaction revenue from payments (at least in the mass-market retail space) is asymptotic to zero. Payments are becoming a commodity and they’ll soon be vanishing inside the transaction itself. At every conference I go to nowadays, people point towards the retailer apps as the transaction wrapper and I am sure they are right to be looking in this direction, although there will of course be others.

(As an aside, this has rather an interesting set of implications for incumbent players since I cannot even remember whether I’ve loaded a Visa card or MasterCard into my apps let alone which issuer the cards came from. I just don’t care, and I’m pretty sure a great many other consumers won’t care either, especially when the app provider offers them double loyalty points to go straight to the bank account.)

The incisive point in Peter’s comment is that it will be the relationship that is the source of the value around the transaction and that will be what the stakeholders will pay for. Obviously, in order to have a relationship the counterparties have to know (let’s set aside what that means for a moment) who each other is. They have to be able to recognise each other. And over time the relationship, and the history of the transactions associated with that relationship, become a most valuable asset indeed: a reputation. This is what we have taken to calling the “3Rs” strategy for businesses who want to exploit the triple-A technology play of authentication, apps and APIs that we have been advising them on for a couple of years.

That means that the future value – literally and figuratively – will accrue to the platform and the apps and the third parties that operate, power and enable the layers around payment that get consumers to buy more things.

[From 2013 – The Unexpected Power Shift In Payments | PYMNTS.com]

Well, not more things, necessarily, because the retailer’s goal might be to get you to buy more expensive things instead, but Karen was certainly correct, provided that the payments layer can be made to work properly. And that means a payments layer that is less vertically integrated, because it cannot predict or constrain the apps that will use it, and it should consume standard services from below (authentication being a good example).

One answer to Peter’s question, then, is that the merchants won’t pay twice, because the payment will be free. A potential commercial structure is that the merchant will pay for the recognition, they will manage the relationship themselves and they will sell the reputation on. Sounds plausible.


  1. I know there are many who have been trying to get the data around a transaction right for years now… I just wonder why it hasn’t happened yet?

    My view is the companies that get data don’t get payments, and the companies that get payments don’t get data.

    … and the companies that get both don’t get airtime (Like Birdback or Tryum)…

    I thought beyondanalysis had a real shot, until their CTO left to join ethereum.

  2. David,

    Somehow I ended up here based on clicking some link on LinkedIN. the conversation is topical even today yet we have not yet moved, at least here in the USA towards the place you speak of. A bit of math there are still 1.2 Billion Branded Debit and Credit cards with only 115 million households in the USA.

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to our newsletter

You have successfully subscribed to the newsletter

There was an error while trying to send your request. Please try again.

By accepting the Terms, you consent to Consult Hyperion communicating with you regarding our events, reports and services through our regular newsletter. You can unsubscribe anytime through our newsletters or by emailing us.
%d bloggers like this:
Verified by MonsterInsights